This Mirror Doesn't Flip Left and Right
- Thank you to Brilliant for supporting PBS.
Hey, smart people, Joe here.
You know, when you think about it, it is incredible
just how symmetric the human body is.
I mean, our left and right side are basically mirror images.
I mean, sure, we've all got some minor differences,
but my right side is basically the same as,
sorry, I held on my left hand when I said right.
What I was trying to say was that my right side
is basically the same as,
(chuckles) it's really weird.
I seem to be confused today.
Just let me,
just hold on.
Right, okay.
This old trick should work.
Left, right, left.
You know, there's only one possible explanation
for what's going on here.
This must be
a different universe. (whimsical music)
A mirror universe.
(whimsical music)
If you hold clock up to a mirror,
you see that instead of the numbers going clockwise,
they go the other way, counterclockwise.
Mirrors seem to flip the whole world
so that everything that we're used to seeing on the right
is on the left.
Why do mirrors do this?
What's really weird is that not everything
looks reversed in a mirror.
I mean, this chair just looks like a normal chair,
and well, take this cup.
It looks like a normal cup,
except that the writing on the cup is reversed.
So maybe mirrors only do their reversal magic
on words, and numbers, and not furniture.
That doesn't make any sense. (glass shatters)
(cat yowls)
I mean, the left and right side of this mirror
are the same as the top and bottom.
They're smooth, they're shiny,
why are only the left and right flipped?
Why isn't my head on the bottom of my feet on top?
Like they are in this mirror.
And why does this mirror not reverse left and right?
My left hand is the left hand of my reflection
and right points to his right.
Mirrors are weird.
And it's about time you learn how they really work.
To really understand the magic of a mirror,
it might help to leave our three-dimensional world
behind for a sec and enter Flatland.
A world inhabited only by flat two-dimensional characters.
It's a pretty plain existence.
(Joe chuckles) (crickets chirping)
Let's move on.
Meet Mister Triangle and Miss Square.
When they look in the mirror,
each of them just sees a line.
But from our three-dimensional point of view,
we can see their whole reflection.
If we imagine sliding Miss Square into the mirror,
she can cover or superpose her reflection point for point
without turning her around.
In other words, she's symmetric.
But if we imagine sliding Mister Triangle into the mirror,
there's no way he can cover his mirror image
without us rotating him in a higher dimension.
Which would be a very strange experience for him.
Mister Triangle is asymmetric.
He can't be superposed on his reflection.
In Flatland, a heart is asymmetric
if it approaches the mirror like this,
but it's symmetric if it looks in the mirror like this.
it has an axis of symmetry running up and down.
A line that divides it in half.
And if you put the edge of a mirror along this axis,
you get the original shape.
Different shapes in Flatland have different numbers
of axis of symmetry.
A circle actually has infinite axis of symmetry,
except poor Mister Parallelogram,
no access for you.
You're just as asymmetric as they come.
So we've been playing around
in this imaginary two-dimensional land
to hopefully give you a hint about what it is
that mirrors really do.
So just like 2D shapes can have a 1D line of symmetry,
3D shapes can have a 2D plane of symmetry.
Take this cone.
It actually has infinite planes of symmetry
rotating around its center here.
And if we slice along one of those,
we get two half cones.
Each of them completes the other.
It's as if we slid it into the mirror
and it overlaps with itself.
This happens because the mirror is parallel
with the plane of symmetry.
But what if we point the cones
so that the mirror is now at a right angle
to the plane of symmetry?
Suddenly, what we see in the mirror
doesn't really line up anymore.
It's been reversed.
Now, we could imagine rotating this cone into the mirror
so that its point was facing out.
But what about these?
There's no way to rotate a hand around
so that it neatly totally lines up with its reflection.
Shapes like these that are the mirror image of each other,
but they can't be superposed on each other,
they're called enantiomorphs,
which is a cool word.
Left and right shoes are enantiomorphs.
So are your ears, or a helix,
or spring that curls right
and another that curls left.
Same but different.
And this is why mirrors seem to reverse left and right,
because they actually don't reverse left and right.
They reverse forward and back.
You are looking at your in enantiomorphic self.
To make this forward/backward reversal more clear,
take a look at this pencil.
When I face the pencil to the left,
well, the mirror pencil is also pointing to the left.
If I point it up, then the antipencil is also pointing up.
But if I point the pencil into the mirror,
well, then the mirror pencil
is pointing the opposite direction.
Back at me.
Hmm, watch this.
The tip of that pencil is maybe three centimeters away
from the mirror,
and the eraser end is maybe 20 centimeters away.
The mirror has simply reversed these coordinates
along this axis,
so that the anti tip is minus three centimeters
and the anti eraser is minus 20.
Or let's say that this side of the mirror is east
and this side is west.
When I point west, mirror me points west too.
But if say, this is north and this is south,
when I point north, mirror me points south.
But if mirrors flip back to front,
then why does text look reversed left to right?
Because it's us that's doing the reversing.
Mirrors are just showing us what we show them.
See, mirrors don't reverse text at all.
You just gotta know how to speak their language.
Now that you know how mirrors really work,
we can have some fun with them.
Now, normally, mirrors make text look reversed
because we reverse it.
Just as we'd expect.
But I happen to have here a doohickie.
And this prevents this mirror from reversing
how it normally would.
Of course, that's a trick.
I actually showed it to the mirror upside down.
Each letter in this word is symmetric
along a horizontal axis.
So when I present it to the mirror,
flipped along that axis,
we can read the reflection normally.
While this word,
because I flipped it along a vertical axis, is reversed.
You can even play a trick on your friends
by writing out words like these,
and then telling them that your magic mirror
doesn't reverse red text.
or that your magic mirror can turn pi into pi.
You know, that mirror from earlier
that didn't reverse images?
That's actually two mirrors.
They're carefully aligned edge to edge at a right angle.
The image is actually reflected back to you twice,
reversing the reversal to unreverse it.
And yes, in a mirror like this,
you see yourself as others actually see you.
So why do people say that mirrors reverse left and right
when they clearly don't?
I think we just lack the right language to
describe what we're seeing
because we rarely put concepts like these into words.
I don't know, maybe for four-dimensional people,
this is very easy,
but for us lowly 3D humans,
we imagine it's actually us inside the mirror looking back.
And since we know what our right and left are,
well, we know what their right and left are.
So a mirror can teach us interesting lessons
about geometry and physics,
but they might also be able to teach us
something about ourselves.
An evolutionary psychologist named Gordon Gallup
did a famous experiment
where he put a mirror in front of some chimpanzees.
At first, they attacked the reflection that they saw
as if it was a stranger,
but pretty quickly,
they started to use the mirror the way that we do.
To look at themselves,
cleaning their teeth,
grooming their bodies,
but did they know that that was them?
Well, the chimps were put to sleep temporarily
and a red mark was dabbed on their face.
When they woke up, they looked at the mirror
and they touched their fingers to the paint on their faces,
not to their reflections.
Along with bonobos, orangutans,
and a few other species,
there's only a handful of animals that recognize
that what they see in the mirror is themselves.
And any species that can recognize itself in a mirror,
not only has a mind of its own,
but also has the potential to recognize
that other creatures have their own minds.
And to express empathy and complex emotions like that.
But humans are special among this group,
because we not only realize
that what we see in the mirror is us,
but also, that it's not exactly us.
Plus, I'd like to see a chimpanzee make this video.
Stay curious.
And thank you to Brilliant for supporting PBS.
Brilliant is an online learning platform
for STEM with hands-on interactive lessons.
This platform is for curious learners,
both young and old, professional, and inexperienced.
You'll get to see science in a new way
through visual examples.
For example, for those who wanna strengthen
their physics knowledge,
you can begin Brilliant's Scientific Thinking course,
where you can explore the laws of physics,
and the principles of engineering,
and the rules that make them work
while solving puzzles.
To learn more about Brilliant,
go to brilliant.org/BeSmart.
Oh, hey guys, it's me, Mirror Joe.
Now that that other guy's gone,
I just wanna say thank you to everybody
who supports the show on Patreon.
We could not make videos like this without you
in this dimension or any other one.
If you'd like to know how you can support the show,
we'd really appreciate it,
if you click the link down in description.
And, well, that other guy will see you in the next video.
I probably won't be there.
One more thing before you go.
Our friends over on "It's Lit!" have launched a podcast.
It is hosted by the amazing Princess Weekes.
"Its Lit! Unabridged,"
features all of your favorite literature topics,
and thoughtful, funny conversations from amazing authors.
It's basically like joining the best book club ever
but you don't have to read anything.
Sounds like a win-win.
You can check out the "Its Lit!" podcast
in the link in the description below.
(Joe gulping)
I'm so thirsty when I shoot.
Hmm. (man laughing)
Oh, hi.
Hold on.
Don't you judge what I do in my free time.
I find it calming.
[Man] Okay.
