Is it proper grammar for は to be used here to denote a question? Is it's function more akin to か? It seems to be incorrect, according to pages 520-521 of Makino & Tsutsui's "A Dictionary of Basic Japanese Grammar." Thank you for your input! :)

Learning Japanese Forum - Ask a Tutor
1

Is it proper grammar for は to be used here to denote a question? Is it’s function more akin to か? It seems to be incorrect, according to pages 520-521 of Makino & Tsutsui’s
“A Dictionary of Basic Japanese Grammar.” Thank you for your input! :slight_smile:

2

In the text above it is really not part of a question but more part of a greeting and is fine. That is how you say hello in Japanese. I wouldn’t worry too much about the grammar at this point. Just go through the lessons and see how they say things. With enough exposure the grammar explanations will start to make more sense. But, far more important to just get exposure to the language and let your brain get used to it.

1 Like
3

Yes, は? can be used as an abbreviation to the question 〜は何ですか. It’s a basic phrase which you’ll find in most introductory textbooks.

It doesn’t contradict Makino and Tsutsui’s explanation either. They just don’t cover that usage on those pages.

4

Awesome feedback, thanks for much! I said “seems” as I knew I could TOTALLY be wrong haha! :joy::sob: But really, I appreciate the background; just helps me grasp these things better.
Take care! :sparkles::blush::sparkles:
Kim

1 Like