LingQ Forum

It looks like you are using an old version of Internet Explorer (IE6). We do our best to support IE6, but the site will work much better if you use a more up to date browser. We strongly recommend you upgrade to:
Question:Du kannst should be du kennst?
Term:kannst
Lesson: Anfänger ohne Vorkenntnisse, 1. Beginner - Willkommen hier!
I think there is a mistake. The sentence "Du kannst nur wenige Worte?" doesn't make sense--"You can only a few words?" I think they meant to type "Du kennst" which would mean "You KNOW only a few words?" Is that right, or am I missing something?
There's a difference between the German 'können' and the English modal verb 'can - be able to'. In English you always have to use the modal with a main verb, unless you use it in a short answer or statement (yes, we can), where the main verb is implied. Of course, it's similar in German, but the use of 'können' without a main verb it taken further than in English, it can even have an object: Kannst du Deutsch? Ich kann Englisch und Französisch. The implied verbs may be sprechen, verstehen, lesen, schreiben; 'können' here is used like 'beherrschen' (to master). Similarly in your example the implied main verbs could be 'sprechen, übersetzen, verstehen'; because you have learned these words you can say them, use them, understand them. In German we say: Wenn du es gelernt hast, kannst du es. I might ask someone if they have learned a poem or a list of words: Kannst du es? Kannst du sie? i.e. Can you recite it, can you use them?
Your interpretation is not wrong, it just shows a problem of the English verb 'know', which can be used for German 'kennen', 'wissen' and 'können' (in the above sense).
'Du kennst nur wenige Worte' - you are acquainted with just a few words. 'Du kannst nur wenige Worte' - you know how to say or use them, you understand them because you have learned them (Du kannst sie).
Think of this problem from the point of view of a German learner of English, you can guess what mistakes they might make :-)
Danke! Ich verstehe.
To comment login or sign up for a free account